Version 1 (modified by, 7 years ago) (diff)


A Tutorial on Systematic Experimental Design

Step I: Single Node

Step II: Small Topology

Image Map

1. Software Configuration

Once we have installed the software on the VM, we may need to configure the software, and automate the configuration process for every node used in an experiment. For this tutorial, since we are setting a virtual routing environment, we will need to configure the routing protocol (e.g., OSPF protocol) for XORP. Again, let's start with the smallest reasonable topology, which is a four-router virtual topology as shown below. The reason that we chose the four-router topology is that we need at least one pair of routers that are not directly connected to each other and each router must have at least two virtual interfaces.

No image "4node-config.png" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup

a. Create Virtual Network

As we have mentioned, a four-router topology is the smallest topology to configure and verify the OSPF routing. In this part, we illustrate how to create a virtual network with four virtual routers.

Create four VMs from the same InstaGENI aggregate and add the links. Modify each VM's name and load the custom image by following Load Custom Image.

No image "4node-topo.png" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup

ii. Configure Virtual Interfaces

Configure the virtual interfaces' IP addresses of each link by clicking No image "info.jpg" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup at the link icon.

No image "lan-config.png" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup

After configuring all the links, submit the request at the bottom of your canvas.

iii. Save the Current RSpec and Submit the Request

For version control purpose, It is important to save (or export) the user request RSpec at each step. Thus, when all VMs are ready for login, we save a copy of current RSpec as 4node-v1.rspec. We can do so by clicking the View and choosing Preview requested document(s) from the pull-down list. You will see the RSpec generated by Flack looks like the following:

<rspec type="request" generated_by="Flack" generated="2014-08-07T22:23:33Z" xsi:schemaLocation=" " xmlns:flack="" xmlns:client="" xmlns:xsi="" xmlns="">
  <node client_id="router-2" component_manager_id="" exclusive="false" xmlns:rs="">
    <rs:vnode name="pcvm3-13" xmlns=""/>
    <sliver_type name="emulab-xen">
      <disk_image url=""/>
    <interface client_id="xen:if0">
      <ip address="" netmask="" type="ipv4"/>
      <flack:interface_info addressBound="false" bound="false"/>
    <interface client_id="xen:if1">
      <ip address="" netmask="" type="ipv4"/>
      <flack:interface_info addressBound="false" bound="false"/>
    <interface client_id="xen:if2">
      <ip address="" netmask="" type="ipv4"/>
      <flack:interface_info addressBound="false" bound="false"/>
    <flack:node_info x="422" y="170" unbound="true"/>

Choose Save to file to export the RSpec. In this tutorial, we assume the file is saved to 4node-v1.rspec, but you can choose any name as you like.

No image "export-to-file.jpg" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup

b. Manually Configure OSPF for XORP

In this tutorial, we configure each VM as an virtual router running OSPF routing protocol. Examples of XORP configurations can be found at XORPExamples. For each VM runs as a software router, the OSPF configuration file is named as ospfd.conf and stored at /etc/xorp/.

We first configure OSPF on router-1. The configuration file can be downloaded from here.

There are several key information we observed by manually creating the OSPF configuration file for router-1.

  • Interface Information
    interface eth1 {
        description: "virtual interface-eth1"
        disable: false
        discard: false
        vif eth1 {
            disable: false
            address {
    		 prefix-length: 24
     		 disable: false
    interface eth2 {
  • OSPF Metrics
    protocols {
        ospf4 {
            area {
    	    interface eth1 {
    	        vif eth1 {
    	          address {
    	            interface-cost 10
    	            hello-interval 5
    	            router-dead-interval 10
    	            disable: false
                interface eth2 {

To simplify the configuration process, we assume the interface-cost is 10 and the hello-interval for every virtual interface. So the main information we need from each node is the virtual interface's address and its prefix-length, as well as the router's router-id that is required for the protocol section in the configuration file.

Similarly, we manually create ospfd.conf under /etc/xorp/ for the other three virtual routers (see `router-2`, `router-3`, and `router-4`).

c. Start XORP and Verify the Routing

i. Start XORP Process

Start XORP by specifying the routing protocol configuration file.

xuanliu@router-1:~$ cd /usr/local/xorp/sbin/
xuanliu@router-1:/usr/local/xorp/sbin$sudo ./xorp_rtrmgr -b /etc/xorp/ospfd.conf -l /tmp/xorp_rtrmgr_log -d

Verify the XORP process is running

xuanliu@router-1:/usr/local/xorp/sbin$ ps -ef | grep xorp
root      1972     1  0 13:30 ?        00:00:02 xorp_fea
root      1973     1  0 13:30 ?        00:00:00 xorp_rib
root      1974     1  0 13:30 ?        00:00:00 xorp_policy
root      1975     1  0 13:30 ?        00:00:01 xorp_ospfv2
root      1976     1  0 13:30 ?        00:00:00 ./xorp_rtrmgr -b /etc/xorp/ospfd.conf -l /tmp/xorp_rtrmgr_log -d

Note that there is no one-key method to stop XORP process, so we have to kill every XORP-related process. We can use the command like the one below to kill all XORP process at one time.

ps -ef | grep xorp_ | /usr/bin/awk '{ if ( $1 == "root" ) {print "sudo kill -9 " $2}}' | sh

ii. Verify the Routing

Login to router-1 and view the OSPF routing table:

xuanliu@router-1:/usr/local/xorp/sbin$ sudo ./xorpsh
Welcome to XORP v1.8.5 on
Version tag: 00000000  Build Date: 2014-06-05 17:11 64-bit> show route table ipv4 unicast ospf	[ospf(110)/20]
		> to via eth2/eth2	[ospf(110)/20]
		> to via eth1/eth1	[ospf(110)/20]
		> to via eth2/eth2

Login to router-3 and view the OSPF routing table:

xuanliu@router-3:/usr/local/xorp/sbin$ sudo ./xorpsh
Welcome to XORP v1.8.5 on
Version tag: 00000000  Build Date: 2014-06-05 17:11 64-bit> show route table ipv4 unicast ospf	[ospf(110)/20]
		> to via eth2/eth2	[ospf(110)/20]
		> to via eth1/eth1	[ospf(110)/20]
		> to via eth2/eth2>

Since router-1 and router-3 are not directly connected, by OSPF routing, we should be able to run ping and traceroute between them.

xuanliu@router-3:/usr/local/xorp/sbin$ ping
PING ( 56(84) bytes of data.
64 bytes from icmp_req=1 ttl=63 time=2.15 ms
64 bytes from icmp_req=2 ttl=63 time=1.45 ms
64 bytes from icmp_req=3 ttl=63 time=1.41 ms
--- ping statistics ---
3 packets transmitted, 3 received, 0% packet loss, time 2003ms
rtt min/avg/max/mdev = 1.411/1.673/2.152/0.342 ms
xuanliu@router-3:/usr/local/xorp/sbin$ traceroute
traceroute to (, 30 hops max, 60 byte packets
 1  router-2-lan1 (  0.652 ms  0.595 ms  0.563 ms
 2  router-1-lan0 (  1.146 ms  1.106 ms  1.076 ms

d. Automate OSPF Configuration

By understanding the syntax of the OSPF configuration file for XORP, we are able to automate the OSPF configuration for every virtual router in a topology, assuming these virtual routers are identical. You can download the automation scripts from XORPAutoStart.

i. Test the Automation

To test it, you will need to login to each router (e.g., router-3) and run the You will see the output similar to the following:

dhcp89-69-127:~ xliu$ ssh -p 30781  -i /Users/xliu/.ssh/id_rsa
Welcome to Ubuntu 12.04 LTS (GNU/Linux 3.2.0-56-generic x86_64)

 * Documentation:
Last login: Mon Jun 30 14:56:51 2014 from
xuanliu@router-3:~$ cd /local
xuanliu@router-3:/local$ wget
xuanliu@router-3:/local$ tar -zxvf xorp_autostart.tar.gz
xuanliu@router-3:/local/xorp_autostart$ /bin/bash
2014-07-01 06:56:28 AM
XORP dir exist
xorp is already added to the group
xorp is running, stop it first
XORP is starting ......
Not doing pidfile...

The key procedure is to obtain the virtual interface's address and its prefix of the subnet information.

In the install script, the Following components are the key parts to generate ospfd.conf.

  • Get Hostname and virtual interface information, and store it into a file (vm_info.txt)
    hostname | sudo tee vm_info.txt > /dev/null
    /sbin/ifconfig | egrep 'eth|inet addr' | sudo tee -a vm_info.txt > /dev/null
    A sample vm_info.txt is available at SampleVMInfo
  • Create ospfd.conf by running an awk script, available from here
    sudo /usr/bin/awk -f $ABS_PATH/ospfd-conf-gen.awk $vm_info_file "$timestamp" 24 | sudo tee $ABS_PATH/ospfd.conf > /dev/null
    A sample ospfd.conf is available at SampleOSPFConf

  • Start XORP Process
    $sudo ./xorp_rtrmgr -b /etc/xorp/ospfd.conf -l /tmp/xorp_rtrmgr_log -d

The complete shell script to wrap up the above procedures is available at StartXORP

Note Please go to [ HOWTOWriteInstallScript] for details on how to write an install script.

Next we are going to install the automate script as an install script at the postboot stage.

If you plan to use the same slice to do the next step, please delete your existing resources in your slice at this time, otherwise you can create a new slice to continue.

e. Install Script

Launch Flack for your slice, and import the RSpec 4node-v1.rspec we just saved.

Click Import and select Import from file from the pull-down list, then select 4node-v1.rspec from the location where you have just saved to, and confirm it. You will see the four-node topology on your canvas, and each node has been configured to have the custom image.

No image "import-rspec-from-file.png" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup

Now, we are ready to add an install script by editing the node property. For each node, click No image "info.jpg" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup to see the node information. By clicking No image "add-service-btn.png" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup, we are able to add a service that usually refers to an install script. In this tutorial, we will enter the link, and the install path is set as /local. By clicking No image "add-exe-serv-btn.png" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup, we can add the commend that execute the install script.

No image "node-install-service.png" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup

Once we added the service and the execute service in Flack, apply the changes and submit the VM reservation request, the OSPF configuration file will be automatically created and the XORP will be started at each virtual router once it is initialized. Setting up the install script will automate installation or configuration process at every node's postboot stage, and we do not need to login to every node to run manually.

2. Impact to Request RSpec

Whenever we make a change to node information or link information in Flack, the user request RSpec is modified accordingly. In other words, we can rely on Flack to easily modify the request RSpec.

Now let's take a look at how the steps Load a Custom Image and Adding Install Scripts will modify the request RSpec. For instance, before adding the custom image and install scripts, the RSpec describing router-1 was like:

<node client_id="router-1" component_manager_id="" component_id="" component_name="pc3" exclusive="false">
    <vnode name="pcvm3-3" xmlns=""/>
    <location latitude="37.43" longitude="-122.17" country="US"/>
    <interface client_id="xen-0:if0">
      <ip address="" netmask="" type="ipv4"/>
      <flack:interface_info addressBound="true" bound="false"/>
    <interface client_id="xen-0:if1">
      <ip address="" netmask="" type="ipv4"/>
      <flack:interface_info addressBound="true" bound="false"/>
    <flack:node_info x="150" y="407" unbound="true"/>

First, when we added the custom image (see Load a Custom Image), a new tag <sliver> will be added to router-1's RSpec, which is

  <sliver_type name="emulab-xen">
      <disk_image url=""/>

Secondly, when we added the install scripts (see Adding Install Scripts), a new tag <service> will be added to router-1's RSpec, which is

      <execute command="/bin/bash /local/xorp_autostart/" shell="sh"/>
      <install install_path="/local" url=""/>

This indicates that we can add custom image and postboot scripts by directly modifying the request RSpec, this is helpful when we have a larger topology.

Save the RSpec as 4node-v2.rspec at this stage, we will load this RSpec in the next step to get the same setup.

3. Script to Capture Routing Table Periodically

In this tutorial, one metric we would like to evaluate is how often the routing table will be updated when there is a link/node failure. To emulate a link failure, we can disable the virtual interfaces, and to emulate a virtual router failure, we can stop the XORP process at the virtual router. A short script (downloaded from here is available to be loaded as an install script.

Delete any existing resources or create a new slice, LOAD the RSpec 4node-v2.rspec, and add a new install service to every node in Flack. Now, the service portion for each node becomes to

      <execute command="/bin/bash /local/xorp_autostart/" shell="sh"/>
      <install install_path="/local" url=""/>
      <install install_path="/local" url=""/>

After adding the new install script to every node, send the resource reservation request. When all nodes are ready to login, we save the new modified RSpec as 4node-v3.rspec.

In the next step, we will add two end hosts to current four-node topology, so now we can delete existing resources from the current slice.

4. Add End Hosts and Install iperf

Once we have verified the routing functions for the virtual router, we add end hosts to validate the end-to-end communication. As the figure shows below, we create the same four-node topology by loading 4node-v3.rspec in Flack, and create two more VMs as a client and a server, and add two virtual links. For client and server, we select regular Ubuntu 12.04 OS in the node information, so we need to install iperf separately. We can also write a script to install iperf to the client and server, and the script can be loaded as an install script.

The install scripts for client and server can be downloaded from here.

No image "4node-add-endhosts.png" attached to XuanSandbox/SmallTopo/DesignSetup

SAVE the new RSpec to 4node-v4.rspec.

Small Topology: Introduction

Small Topology: Execute

Attachments (27)

Download all attachments as: .zip