Changes between Version 5 and Version 6 of GEC13Agenda/WiMAXPlanning


Ignore:
Timestamp:
03/07/12 14:27:42 (8 years ago)
Author:
hmussman@bbn.com
Comment:

--

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • GEC13Agenda/WiMAXPlanning

    v5 v6  
    21218:30am  [[BR]]
    2222
    23 == 2)  GENI WiMAX Strategy ==
    24 Harry Mussman (GPO)  [[BR]]
    25 
    26 
    27 
    28 == 3)  GENI WiMAX Site Deployment Status and Plans ==
    29 
    30 
    31 === 3.1)  Airspan Profile-C Base Station, with Associated Hardware and Software ===
    32 Ivan Seskar (WINLAB) and Harry Mussman (GPO) [[BR]]
    33 
    34 
    35 === 3.2)  WINLAB/Rutgers University Site Extension Plan ===
     23
     24== 2)  GENI WiMAX Site Deployment Status and Plans ==
     25
     26
     27=== 2.1)  BBN Site Extension Plan ===
     288:35am  Manu Gosain and Harry Mussman (GPO)
     29
     30
     31=== 2.2)  WINLAB/Rutgers University Site Extension Plan ===
     328:40am  [[BR]]
    3633Ivan Seskar (WINLAB) [[BR]]
    3734
    38 
    39 === 3.2)  UCLA Site Extension Plans ===
     35At WINLAB:  Replace NEC BS on roof with Airspan BS (currently at WINLAB)  [[BR]]
     36Retain at WINLAB:  NEC BS in sandbox [[BR]]
     37
     38At Bush Campus:  Install Airspan BS [[BR]]
     39Choice of frequency: 2610MHz [[BR]]
     40
     41x1  (2510 Mid:  2560MHz to 2630MHz)  [[BR]]
     42
     43
     44=== 2.3)  UCLA Site Extension Plans ===
     458:45am  [[BR]]
    4046Giovanni Pau (UCLA) and Mario Gerla (UCLA) [[BR]]
    4147
    42 === 3.3)  Clemson University Site Deployment Plan ===
     48[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/110411%20%20UCLA%20%20WiMAX%20%20BBN-GENI-GEC12.ppt  slides]  [[BR]]
     49
     50Add x1 Airspan BS near UCLA dormitories;  possibly other BSs.  [[BR]] 
     51Choice of frequency:  2572MHz [[BR]]
     52
     53x1  (2510 Mid:  2560MHz to 2630MHz)  [[BR]]
     54
     55=== 2.4)  Clemson University Site Deployment Plan ===
     568:55am  [[BR]]
    4357K-C Wang (Clemson)
    4458
    45 
    46 === 3.4)  University of Wisconsin Site Extension Plan ===
    47 Suman Banerjee (Wisconsin)  [[BR]]
    48 
    49 
    50 === 3.5)  University of Michigan Site Deployment Plan ===
     59Add x1 Airspan BS near campus [[BR]]
     60Add x2 Airspan BS near Greenville;  connect via DOT fibers.
     61
     62Want handover near I85/I385 intersection.  [[BR]]
     63
     64Utilize Clemson existing Educational Broadband Services (EBS) license?  [[BR]] 
     65
     66 
     67=== 2.5)  University of Wisconsin Site Extension Plan ===
     689:05am  [[BR]]
     69Suman Banerjee (Wisconsin) and Derek Meyer (Wisconsin)  [[BR]]
     70
     71[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/UW-Madison_GEC12_Wimax.ppt slides]  [[BR]]
     72
     73Considering expansion to two possible locations:  Madison Metro;  and Dept of ? near Capitol.
     74
     75x1 (2510 Mid:  2560MHz to 2630MHz)  [[BR]]
     76
     77Connect via Madison unified fiber project  [[BR]]
     78Outside contributions for power and poles.  [[BR]]
     79
     80=== 2.6)  University of Michigan Site Deployment Plan ===
     819:15am [[BR]]
    5182Morley Mao  (Michigan)  [[BR]]
    5283
    53 
    54 === 3.6)  Wayne State University Site Deployment Plan ===
     84[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/wimaxGEC12Michigan.pptx  slides]  [[BR]]
     85
     86No EBS license;  working with Wayne State on licenses.  [[BR]]
     87
     88Identified several roof-top locations;  aesthetics approval required.  [[BR]]
     89
     90Will signals penetrate into buildings?  [[BR]]
     91
     92=== 2.7)  Wayne State University Site Deployment Plan ===
     939:25am   [[BR]]
    5594Hongwei Zhang (Wayne State)  [[BR]]
    5695
    57 ===  3.7)  Discussion of Deployment Issues and Suggestions from Current Sites ===
    58 Moderator:  Harry Mussman (GPO)  [[BR]]
     96[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/WayneWiMAX-deployment-plan-GEC12.pdf  slides] [[BR]]
     97
     98Considering: one site with three sectors;  three separated sites.  [[BR]] 
     99
     100Wayne State had EBS spectrum in 2.6GHz band, but leased out to Clearwire.  [[BR]]
     101Talking with Clearwire about loan of frequencies;  concerns about their need to change frequencies, and radiation into Canada.  [[BR]]
     102
     103Possibly consider 3.65GHz band, with Intel 6250 modem, where no interference?  Concerns about:  coverage;  lack of MS devices.  [[BR]]
     104
     105=== 2.7)  Temple University Site Deployment Plan ===
     1069:35am   [[BR]]
     107Hongwei Zhang (Wayne State)  [[BR]]
     108
     109=== 2.7)  Drexel University Site Deployment Plan ===
     1109:40am   [[BR]]
     111Hongwei Zhang (Wayne State)  [[BR]]
     112
     113=== 2.8 UMass Amherst Update ===
     1149:45am   [[BR]]
     115
     116=== 2.9 NYU Poly Site Update ===
     1179:50am   [[BR]]
     118
     119=== 2.10 Univ of Colorado at Boulder Site Update ===
     1209:55am   [[BR]]
     121
     122=== 2.11 Columbia University Site Update ===
     12310am   [[BR]]
    59124
    60125==  4)  Break ==
    61 10am  [[BR]]
     12610:05am  [[BR]]
    62127
    63128== 5)  GENI WiMAX Deployment and Strategy Issues ==
    6412910:30am  [[BR]]
    65 
     130===  3.7)  Discussion of Deployment Issues and Suggestions from Current Sites ===
     1311:55pm   [[BR]]
     132Moderator:  Harry Mussman (GPO)  [[BR]]
     133
     134Round-robin discussion, with a focus on deployment issues.  [[BR]]
     135
     136NOTE:  Sol 3 (and Sol 2) projects:  FORWARD your issues ahead of time, and they will be summarized here.  [[BR]]
    66137
    67138== 6)  GENI WiMAX Experiments ==
     
    72143== 7) Adjourn ==
    7314411:30am  [[BR]]
     145
     146
     147== References ==
     148
     149
     150=== R1  GENI WiMAX Strategy ===
     151Harry Mussman (GPO) [[BR]]
     152
     153a)  Goals for GENI WiMAX site deployments: [[BR]]
     154  Satisfy needs of local research experiments [[BR]]
     155  Support multi-site experiments, e.g., MobilityFirst   [[BR]]
     156  Support remote experimenters [[BR]]
     157
     158  Support multi-site applications? [[BR]]
     159
     160  Are we missing something?  support for instruction? [[BR]]
     161
     162b)  Sol 2 base station deployments: [[BR]]
     163  Update to include OMF/OML structures, including LoginService [[BR]]
     164  Add GENI AM API [[BR]]
     165
     166  Complete, and update to new software that support multiple VLANs, etc. [[BR]]
     167  Connect via switch to I2 backbone, via OF switches if there [[BR]]
     168
     169  Consider how to setup multi-site slice, and include other GENI resources [[BR]]
     170  Consider federated operation [[BR]]
     171  Consider adding WiFi AP to support dual-homed experiments, e.g., MobilityFirst [[BR]]
     172 
     173c)  Sol 3 base station deployments: [[BR]]
     174  Consider 3.6GHz operation? [[BR]]
     175  Study commercial campus deployments, to understand coverage and applications:  U Colorado, Boulder;  Northern Mich U;  UMass Dartmouth [[BR]]
     176  Order Airspan base stations and related items, for delivery 1/2012 [[BR]]
     177  Complete installation within Spiral 4!  (within 1 year) [[BR]]
     178
     179  Decide on how to provide ASN-GW for handover [[BR]]
     180  Consider open-source ASN-GW?  or ASN-GW from Airspan? [[BR]]
     181  How could we use Wisconsin mobility engine? [[BR]]
     182
     183  [http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/UoC%20-%20MacroMAXe%20RF%20Plan%20V1.1.pptx  Airspan Deployment Plan for Univ Colorado at Boulder][[BR]]
     184
     185d)  Mobile stations: [[BR]]
     186  Reference MS is Linux netbook, with Intel WIMAX modem card, internal or external [[BR]]
     187  Reference vehicular MS? [[BR]]
     188  Reference handset MS?  Need to be able to unlock Sprint-supported device? [[BR]]
     189
     190e)  Experiment support: [[BR]]
     191  Move to OMF/OML, for better support and for easier sharing [[BR]]
     192  Consider alternate techniques for throughput measurements [[BR]]
     193  Consider how to setup multi-site slice, and include other GENI resources [[BR]]
     194
     195  GIMI project committed to supporting WiMAX sites [[BR]]
     196
     197  How can we make it easy for experimenters? [[BR]]
     198
     199f) Other topics: [[BR]]
     200  Interworking with carriers (Clemson) [[BR]]
     201  Use of carrier resources, i.e., WiNTeB [[BR]]
     202  How could we add LTE?  any match of equipment, frequencies and mobile stations? [[BR]]
     203
     204g)  CONCERN: [[BR]]
     205  Do not have resources to do all of the above!  how do we decide? [[BR]]
     206  What is the best way to support campus projects? [[BR]]
     207  What is the best way to support experimenters? [[BR]]
     208
     209
     210=== R2 Airspan Profile-C Base Station, with Associated Hardware and Software ===
     211Ivan Seskar (WINLAB) and Harry Mussman (GPO) [[BR]]
     212
     213 
     214a)  Choice of Airspan to provide a WiMAX base station for new GENI WiMAX sites [[BR]]
     215NEC is not able to provide a WiMAX base station for new GENI WiMAX sites [[BR]]
     216WINLAB and the GPO have decided to purchase base stations from Airspan, a commercial company pursuing target customers such as universities and small carriers. [[BR]]
     217For example, the Univ of Colorado at Boulder IT Dept has installed an Airspan system with 4 sectors, that covers the campus.  They have been pleased with Airspan. [[BR]]
     218WINLAB has a frim quote from Airspan for their MacroMAXe profile-C WiMAX base station unit, and related items. [[BR]]
     219
     220[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/WiMAX_Brochure_Rev_J3.pdf  Airspan brochure][[BR]]
     221[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/MacroMAXe%20Product%20Specification%20_Rel%209%200%201_%20Vx%5B1%5D.pdf  MacroMAXe Product Specification]  [[BR]] 
     222[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/UoC%20-%20MacroMAXe%20RF%20Plan%20V1.1.pptx  Airspan Deployment Plan for Univ Colorado at Boulder][[BR]]
     223
     224b)  Rutgers will provide a kit including: [[BR]]
     225Airspan MacroMAXe profile-C WiMAX base station unit, for outside mounting[[BR]]
     226  Choice of frequency:   [[BR]]
     227  (2510 Lo:  2496MHz to 2570MHz)   [[BR]]
     228  (2510 Mid:  2560MHz to 2630MHz)  [[BR]]
     229  (2510 Hi:  2620MHz to 2690MHz)  [[BR]]
     230  (3650: 3650MHz to 3700MHz)]  [[BR]]
     231
     232NOTE:  WINLAB needs to know frequency choices during November (or early December), so that they can place an order with Airspan for delivery late 2011 or early 2012!
     233
     234Sector antenna, with x4 RF jumper cables [[BR]]
     2352x4 MIMO, supported by base station and antenna [[BR]]
     236GPS antenna, with surge suppressor and cable [[BR]]
     237DC power cable, from base station unit (outside) to testbed (inside) [[BR]]
     238Network management software license, 1 per base station [[BR]]
     239
     240Figure 3-1  Airspan MacroMAXe Base Station with Antenna
     241
     242[[Image(AirspanMacroMAXe.jpg, 50%)]]  [[BR]]
     243
     244
     245c)  Campus will need to provide: [[BR]]
     246Pole for mounting [[BR]]
     247DC power supply (-48v, approx 300W) [[BR]]
     248Ethernet cable, from base station unit (outside) to testbed (inside);  consider copper (may be a problem with lightning surge) or fiber (requires MM fiber cable, and fiber interface on switch) [[BR]]
     249Windows server to host network management software [[BR]]
     250Linux server to host OMF software [[BR]]
     251Ethernet switches, and other network equipment, for access (configuration to be provided) [[BR]]       
     252
     253d)  Additional kits can be purchased from Airspan [[BR]]
     254  Price is approximately $15,000. [[BR]]
     255 
     256e)  It is expected that additional base stations kits will be purchased for some (or all) Sol 3 GENI sites in Spiral 5. [[BR]]
     257  Thus, campus site might be able to add additional sectors, at no cost. [[BR]]
     258  Planning for next year will be done later this year. [[BR]]
     259  Consider including additional sectors within your technical plan right away.   [[BR]]
     260
     261f)  Note:  Airspan indicates that they expect to introduce a new base station unit within the next year. [[BR]]
     262  Somewhat reduced performance/range. [[BR]]
     263  Approximately half the cost [[BR]]
     264
     265g)  Airspan indicates that their sector antenna provides:[[BR]]
     266  A 90degree pattern, which is consistent with proper coverage over a 120degree sector.[[BR]]
     267  Four internal elements, to support 2x4 MIMO.[[BR]]
     268  Airspan can provide provide x4 omni-directional antennas, but the cost is much higher, and the range is signifcantly reduced.[[BR]]
     269
     270h)  Airspan shows that their profile-C base station unit can be configured to operate without an ASN GW and without a RADIUS (authentication) server.[[BR]]
     271  In this mode, a list of allowed base stations must be configured into the base station, and groups of these base stations are mapped to a VLAN on the ethernet port.[[BR]]
     272  This appears to be consistent with the current NEC base station unit operated with the ASN GW/WiMAX RF AggMgr code that has been provided by Rutgers/WINLAB[[BR]]
     273  [http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/CS%20Network%20Configuration%20Setup%20Guide.pdf  MacroMAXe Configuration Guide][[BR]]
     274
     275i)  Airspan shows that if handover operation is desired, an ASN GW must be provided, plus typically an associated RADIUS (authentication) server.[[BR]]
     276  In this case, the base station unit operates with IP at the interface.  [[BR]]
     277
     278
     279
     280=== 4.2)  Throughput Experiment Using iperf ===
     2812:15pm   [[BR]]
     282Manu Gosain (GPO) and Harry Mussman (GPO) [[BR]]
     283
     284Overview of basic throughput experiment, using bidirectional iperf, both TCP and UDP  [[BR]]
     285  [http://groups.geni.net/geni/wiki/OMFWiMAXExperiments#GENIWiMAXExperimentsUsingOMFOML  Basic throughput experiment using OMF/OML]  [[BR]]
     286
     287The basic throughput experiments we have done utilize iperf, both TCP and UDP. [[BR]]
     288  In iperf, the data is generated in the client, and flows to the server. [[BR]]
     289  We put the client in the Mobile Station, and the server in the Base Station. [[BR]]
     290  We used -d dualtest (bidirectional mode), where test is initiated at the client, data begins to flow to the server, and then a second data flow starts at the server;  at the end of the test, results are available at the client. [[BR]]
     291  Because of this, all tests can be initiated at the Mobile Station, and then results are available there. [[BR]]
     292
     293iperf results in the TCP mode depend upon buffer sizes;  overall delay;  and lost packets.   [[BR]]
     294  Because of wireless propagation conditions, lost packets are common, and slight changes can significantly affect the measured throughput. [[BR]]
     295  Thus, TCP results are highly variable;  we took multiple measurements at each point, and identified the best and worst results. [[BR]]
     296  It would certainly be good to have a better way to evaluate available channel bandwidth. [[BR]]
     297  On the other hand, most apps use TCP and the variable results are typical of how these apps would see the channel. [[BR]]
     298
     299iperf results in the UDP mode, counts  % packets received, for a given (fixed) transmit rate. [[BR]]
     300  If the rate is set below the available bandwidth, typically 100% of the packets are received. [[BR]]
     301  If the rate is set above the available bandwidth, typically % of the packets are received typically equals available bandwidth divided by offered bandwidth, but there is no way to understand how many packets are actually lost. [[BR]]
     302  An extended test that ramped up the offered bandwidth in multiple tests, could actually verify the available bandwidth;  this could then be repeated to see real variations in available bandwidth. [[BR]]
     303
     304References:  [[BR]]
     305  [http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/201007-JT_Iperf.pptx  iperf tutorial slides]  [[BR]]
     306  [http://openmaniak.com/iperf.php  iperf tutorial web site][[BR]]
     307
     308=== 4.3)  Throughput Experiment Using Bit Torrent ===
     3092:20pm   [[BR]]
     310Fraida Fund (NYU Poly)   [[BR]]
     311
     312[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/NYU-Poly-WiMAX-BT-Experiment.pdf slides]  [[BR]]
     313
     314Overview of throughput experiment, using bit torrent.  [[BR]]
     315Advantages  [[BR]]
     316
     317[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/NYU-Poly-WiMAX-BT-Experiment.pdf  Reference] [[BR]]
     318[http://witestlab.poly.edu/index.php/wimax/field-measurements.html  More information & source code] [[BR]]
     319[http://witestlab.poly.edu/index.php/component/user/?task=register  Use the NYU-Poly WiMAX testbed]  [[BR]]
     320
     321
     322=== 4.4)  Raw IP and UDP Traffic Generators ===
     3232:25pm  [[BR]]
     324Surat (Au) Teerapittayanon (MIT)  [[BR]]
     325
     326Overview of new raw IP and UDP traffic generators, to accurately gauge available channel bandwidth. [[BR]]
     327[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/GEC12Slides_plusreadme.ppt  slides]  [[BR]]
     328
     329=== 4.5) Using OMF and OML in Your Experiment ===
     3302:30pm  [[BR]]
     331Christoph Dwertmann  (NICTA)  [[BR]]
     332
     333[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/omf-gec10%20copy.pdf  slides] [[BR]]
     334
     335[http://groups.geni.net/geni/wiki/OMFWiMAXExperiments#GENIWiMAXExperimentsUsingOMFOML  Basic throughput experiment using OMF/OML]  [[BR]]
     336
     337OML'ified apps we know of include:[[BR]]
     338  gpslogger[[BR]]
     339  Iperf[[BR]]
     340  omf_nmetrics[[BR]]
     341  omf_trace[[BR]]
     342  otg and otr[[BR]]
     343  wlanconfig_oml[[BR]]
     344  Yantt (Yet another network testing tool)[[BR]]
     345  SNMP wrapper[[BR]]
     346
     347[http://oml.mytestbed.net/projects/omlapp/wiki  Repository for OML'ified apps]  [[BR]]
     348
     349List of available modules with OMF and OML for use in your experiment [[BR]]
     350Approach for adding OMF and OML interfaces to additional modules [[BR]]
     351
     352=== 4.6)  Multiple Site Experiment:  Mobility First ===
     3532:35pm  [[BR]]
     354Kiran Nagaraja (WINLAB)  [[BR]]
     355
     356[http://groups.geni.net/geni/attachment/wiki/GEC12WiMaxDeploymentAndExperimentation/MF-GEC12-PlenaryDemo-10-3-2011.pdf  slides] [[BR]]
     357
     358Overview of current Mobility First multiple-site experiment. [[BR]]
     359
     360What additions are needed?  [[BR]]
     3611)  Add WiFi AP to each site.  [[BR]]
     3622)  L2 path from MS to core  [[BR]]
     363
     364Experiment done without human intervention, by using x2 MAC addresses, and emulating packet loss to fake mobility.  [[BR]]
     365Consider these as possible sites by GEC13:  WINLAB;  BBN;  NYU Poly;  UCLA;  Colorado.  [[BR]]
     366