Subject: Re: ERM questions From: Luisa Nevers Date: 11/2/2011 1:44 PM To: "Michael S. Wang" CC: bergman@ee.columbia.edu, Harry Mussman , Heidi Picher Dempsey Hello Michael, I have finished reviewing the two ERM packages. As noted earlier, I can only review documentation and cannot validate the simulation and the NetFPGA code. I have found no further issues in the latest version and have completed the GIR3.2 evaluation. Thank you for you help, Luisa On 11/1/2011 5:08 PM, Michael S. Wang wrote: > Hi Luisa, > > I've uploaded the ERM wiki with two new files: > > 1. ERM-Simulator.v.1.zip > 2. GENI-ERM-NetFPGA.zip > > Hope this helps. Thanks! > > Warm regards, > Michael > > On Mon, Oct 24, 2011 at 12:00 PM, Luisa Nevers wrote: > > Hi Michael, > > Thank you for the quick response. No rush, good luck on your midterm. > > Luisa > > > On 10/24/2011 11:56 AM, Michael S. Wang wrote: >> Hi Luisa, >> >> Thanks for the feedback. I have updated the descriptions of the two packages on the ERM wiki (based on your previous email). >> >> I will address the others changes by Wednesday as I have a midterm tomorrow evening that I have to prepare for right now. >> >> Thanks! >> >> Warm regards, >> Michael >> >> On Mon, Oct 24, 2011 at 11:39 AM, Luisa Nevers wrote: >> >> Hello Michael, >> >> I have reviewed both packages and here is feedback for the READMEs. As noted earlier, >> I am not able to test the setup, so can only comment on instructions. >> >> geni_umf_v3_3pin package: >> ======================= >> 1. Minor. The README_ERM_Updated.txt "Getting started with Design" section uses the >> project name "reference_nic", it is probably a well known term, but it should be explicitly >> mapped to the geni_umf_v3_3pin project. >> >> 2. In the same section the directories descriptions do not match what is delivered in >> the package: >> - README states "The src directory is empty". In the package, the directory >> contains these files: crypto.v, crypto.v~, user_data_path.v user_data_path.v~. >> - README states "The sw directory is empty". In the package there is no "sw" delivered. >> - README states "There is one file under include". In the package there are two files >> "crypto_defines.v" and "dev_id.v" in addition to "lib_modules.txt" >> >> GENI 10 Simulations 2 Package: >> ========================= >> 3. Readme does not provide an overview that explains the scope of the package. >> >> 4. The "Running the simulator" section does not explain about the simulator, >> and it does not list which simulator the files can be used in. Should include >> Simulator name and version. >> >> Luisa >> >> >> On 10/24/2011 10:07 AM, Luisa Nevers wrote: >>> Hello Michael, >>> >>> Thank you for attaching the 2 packages to the GENI wiki page. I do not see >>> any changes to the GENI ERM page that describes the packages and their >>> relevance. It would be helpful to add text to describe each. >>> >>> I will start reviewing the two packages this morning and will get feedback to you. >>> >>> About the email failure, if possible, could you forward me one of the failure >>> notifications. We have been experiencing some filtering issues, and if the >>> failures are related, I could get our support group to address it. >>> >>> Thank you, >>> Luisa >>> >>> >>> >>> On 10/22/2011 8:37 PM, Michael S. Wang wrote: >>>> >>>> Hi Luisa, >>>> >>>> I've uploaded a new simulation zip file onto the ERM GENI wiki. >>>> >>>> >>>> It is called GENI_10_Simulations_2.zip. >>>> >>>> It contains a readme file that describes how to use the simulation. >>>> >>>> Items 2-4 will be addressed by today as well. >>>> >>>> >>>> Sorry if you got several emails on this. My email system keeps sending me "failure notifications" when I try to send to you. >>>> >>>> Warm regards, >>>> Michael >>>> >>>> On Thu, Oct 20, 2011 at 9:55 AM, Luisa Nevers wrote: >>>> >>>> Hello Micheal, >>>> >>>> Sorry about the delay, I finally got a chance to start checking out this deliverable and >>>> have several questions. >>>> >>>> 1. I have looked at the ERM_Final_Report_Sep11.doc document and do not seen any >>>> usage/installation information. What should I use as documentation to use the >>>> simulation? >>>> >>>> 2. I may not be able to use the NETFPGA code, due to lack of equipment, but I >>>> expect I should be able to build it, right? I have unpacked it, and found that >>>> the README.txt only describes the directory structure of the NETFPGA code and how >>>> the of the deliverable (geni_umf_v3_3pin) fits into that structure. Is there >>>> documentation for building this module? >>>> >>>> 3. Unpacking the geni_umf_v3_3pin.rar file creates approximately 200 files (no directories) >>>> at the top level. How does this map to the structure that is in the README.txt? >>>> >>>> 4. When using unrar to unpack the geni_umf_v3_3pin.rar file, there is around >>>> a dozen prompt to overwrite existing files. Why is taking place? >>>> >>>> Thanks, >>>> Luisa >>>> >>>> >>>> On 10/13/2011 10:30 PM, Michael S. Wang wrote: >>>>> Hi Luisa, >>>>> >>>>> The source code for the ERM project can be found on the GENI ERM wikipage (http://groups.geni.net/geni/wiki/Embedded%20Real-Time%20Measurements). >>>>> >>>>> Under the attachment section, please download the two files: >>>>> >>>>> 1. GENI_10_Simulations.zip >>>>> 2. geni_umf_v3_3pin.rar >>>>> >>>>> Furthermore, the file ERM_Final_Report_Sep11.docx will provide a summary of the entire project and explanations of the code release. >>>>> >>>>> Please let me know if you need anything else. Thanks! >>>>> >>>>> Warm regards, >>>>> Michael >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> On Fri, Oct 7, 2011 at 11:35 AM, Keren Bergman wrote: >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> Hi Mike, >>>>> Please respond to them with the link to our ERM release >>>>> -----Original Message----- >>>>> From: Luisa Nevers [mailto:lnevers@bbn.com] >>>>> Sent: Friday, October 07, 2011 10:28 AM >>>>> To: Luisa Nevers >>>>> Subject: GENI Integration Release 3.2 Candidates >>>>> >>>>> Hello GENI PI, >>>>> >>>>> You are receiving this email because your project has a software >>>>> milestone due within the GENI Spiral 3 Integration Release 2 (GIR3.2) >>>>> time frame. This is the final reminder for GENI Spiral 3. Make sure to >>>>> reply with your software release information if you want to be included >>>>> in the GEC12 list of projects that made Spiral 3 software >>>>> deliverables. Please let me know how to access both the software and >>>>> its supporting documentation. >>>>> >>>>> The GIR 3.2 effort focuses on software released after March 31, 2011. >>>>> For more information about the GIR efforts, please see >>>>> Spiral3_GIR_Guidelines.pdf available at: >>>>> http://groups.geni.net/geni/wiki/GpoDoc#GENISpiral3IntegrationReleaseGuideli >>>>> nes >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> For a detailed list of software milestones being considered for GIR3.2, >>>>> see the full list at: >>>>> http://groups.geni.net/geni/wiki/GIR3_2_candidates >>>>> >>>>> Thank You! >>>>> Luisa Nevers >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >